Hayden H.
9/15/2023
Nice atmosphere, great Philly and onion rings. Service was quick and cordial! Hit this place up if you want a good slice on the quick, or if you want to hang out and watch a game with a draft.
New York Pizza
$
Closed
(43)
Photos
400 E Valley Rd
Carbondale, CO 81623
New York Pizza operates multiple locations in Colorado, including establishments in Aspen, Basalt, and Carbondale. Known for their delicious offerings, the menu features a range of items such as pizza, salads, sandwiches, wings, and a selection of beer.
The Carbondale location is situated at 901 Hwy 133, providing a convenient spot for locals and visitors alike to enjoy quality New York-style pizza. With a focus on fresh ingredients and a diverse menu, New York Pizza aims to satisfy the cravings of its customers in the area.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.043 reviewsMatt W.
8/24/2025
Less than impressed. Very expensive and not much to write home about. Big slices but the crust and sauce lacked flavor and $7 beer is all too much to get me back. Sorry but love good pizza
John G.
7/19/2024
Mediocre, not great. The garlic bread went right into the garbage. There's a barstool right by the register. Don't sit there, because they'll ask to move. If only there was a way to retract the...
Will P.
9/28/2024
leave it up to the bespectacled hipster to screw up something reasonably simple. It's a Philly cheesesteak!! NOT chopped mush on a bun. juat make a damm sandwich quit trying to make it...
Masha Z.
12/27/2019
This is the place to come if you are hangry! You will leave full and happy to deal with the world all over again. The staff is extremely friendly! Don't forget that this is CASH ONLY!!! Oh and the...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.