Robert F.
8/18/2025
Food in Colorado has been marginal. It nice to get a legit bagel that is actually toasted and not just warmed when I ask for toasted. The tomato and onions was flavorful and cold. The coffee was...
Gib's New York Bagels
$
Closed
(57)
Photos
1241 Main St
Windsor, CO 80550
Gib's New York Bagels offers a variety of food items, including bagels that are reportedly tough and lacking in flavor. Despite the criticism of their bagels, some patrons have found other menu items to be tasty.
The restaurant features a drive-through service, though customers have noted slow service times, often taking 6 to 8 minutes per car. Overall, Gib's aims to provide a casual dining experience centered around bagels and other food offerings.
Generated from the web
Also at this address
Reviews
2.557 reviewsSteve K.
10/4/2025
Slowest drive-thru I've ever experienced (frequently, not just one time). Bagels are OK, but seem to have become more inconsistent over the past few years.
Keenan F.
7/26/2025
They got my order wrong and forgot cheese on my bagel sandwich. It was way too expensive for what I got. No other customers inside but it took a minute for them to even notice I was there. The...
Kerry D.
7/6/2025
The restaurant is clean and the staff friendly. I bought a half dozen bagels to go. The bagels were dry, but even worse, they botched the Oder and substituted salt bagels (pretzel, supposedly) for...
N S.
12/15/2024
Check your order! (I know, you shouldn't even have to...) We love the bagels hence the second star. The food is delicious. BUT we also know that anything we add on or change from the menu item...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.