Jessica P.
9/18/2025
FAT SULLY'S NY PIZZA in Colorado Springs came in clutch at 10pm! We were staying at the Marriott Element, which was one block away, and just wanted a slice of pizza before we called it a night....
Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colorado Springs
$
Closed
(294)
Photos
528 S Tejon St
Colorado Springs, CO 80903
Fat Sully's in Colorado Springs, CO, is renowned for its giant slices of New York-style pizza, double patty smash burgers, and indulgent fried chicken sandwiches that have become legendary among locals. The establishment prides itself on serving flavorful fries and sides that enhance the dining experience, inviting guests to gather, relax, and enjoy their meals with both hands.
With a commitment to bold flavors and a vibrant atmosphere, Fat Sully's encourages patrons to indulge in their hearty offerings. This eatery is a go-to destination for those seeking a satisfying and memorable meal in a welcoming setting.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0294 reviews
Eva S.
5/30/2025
We came in around 2pm and were given a table right away. Our server did take a minute to come around to our table to take our drink orders but she was prompt to bring them out. From here, it did...
Abby T.
1/12/2025
After a night of dancing downtown we were hungry and looking for some quick food, luckily this place is open late! The bar inside was still open, we opted to do that instead of using the to-go...
Melanie T.
10/6/2024
My favorite pizza is white sauce but many places don't offer that as an option. So we had to try the white sauce pizza. First, the slices are huge so one slice was good enough to share between my...
Raymond G.
10/28/2025
Felt I was having a slice of pie from Raymond's in Manhattan!!!!! The crust was perfect toppings plentiful and the sauce was just enough. The best part I was able to fold it like a true NY. Pie
See a problem?
