Crissie J.
7/12/2025
Been here 5 years ago and wasn't impressed. It has changed!!! Food was delicious, service was fast and attentive, drinks were fire! We had the mystery shot and it was no mystery that there was...
Fat Sully's NY Pizza - Colfax
$$
Closed
(674)
Photos
3237 E Colfax Ave
Denver, CO 80206
Fat Sully's at Atomic Cowboy in Denver, CO is a haven for those seeking larger-than-life portions of NY-style pizza, double patty smash burgers, and indulgent fried chicken sandwiches. The menu also boasts a variety of flavorful fries and sides that cater to those with hearty appetites. The vibe at Fat Sully's is all about going big and enjoying a memorable dining experience with friends and family.
With a commitment to serving up satisfying meals, Fat Sully's invites guests to relish in their generous offerings and savor every bite. The restaurant prides itself on creating a welcoming atmosphere where patrons can gather, enjoy delicious food, and immerse themselves in a lively dining environment.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5674 reviews
David M.
11/12/2025
Food: Used to love the pizza here. So large. Such a lot of very good pizza for the money! But definitely NOT today. (And yes, I'm sending that as a shout (out) to the world). On Wednesday I buy...
Steve R.
11/14/2025
I checked in at the counter. Staff was cold and rude. Told I was number 2. Waited 20 minutes to be called. I returned to the counter because no one called my name. Pizza was on the rack. Had need...
Shaun R.
4/13/2025
We went here to eat their pizza. We ordered wings as well. Both the wings and pizza were very good and we felt the pricing was fair. Their sweet tea is hands down the best sweet tea I've ever...
Amanda L.
6/17/2024
OMG Denver Biscuit Company (also falls under the name of Atomic Cowboy/Fat Sully's) is absolutely fantastic! Their biscuits are some of the butteriest, moistest, flakiest biscuits I've ever had!...
See a problem?
