Kit W.
6/22/2025
OMG this is my new favorite ice cream. It's light in texture, intense in flavor and not too sweet - just creamy deliciousness. I got a double with a waffle cone ($10.25) and this is *not* cheap...
The Penny Ice Creamery
$
Closed
(375)
Photos
820 41st Ave
Santa Cruz, CA 95062
The Penny Ice Creamery, a Santa Cruz original since 2010, is a beloved ice cream shop that takes pride in crafting their delectable treats completely from scratch. Using local, organic, and seasonal ingredients sourced from trusted farmers, they create flavors like Toasted Marshmallow Fluff that are sure to delight ice cream enthusiasts.
With multiple locations in Santa Cruz, Aptos, Scotts Valley, Los Altos, and Palo Alto, The Penny Ice Creamery offers a range of indulgent desserts, from special sundaes to bon bons and their signature Penny Pop. Their commitment to making everything from scratch ensures a truly unique and flavorful ice cream experience.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0375 reviews
Allie G.
7/21/2025
I'd been to the downtown location of The Penny Ice Creamery before, and this experience was way better! On a Friday night, there was a line out the door but it moved pretty quickly. The interior...
Maleiha S.
6/8/2025
Mini cup of ice cream $7. Got a mini cup of vanilla ice cream topped with the popular marshmallow fluff. My partner got a Carmel bitter ice cream (I think that's the name) with fluff, it tasted...
Benita M.
3/19/2025
It was such a hot day. I was looking for a drink when I stumbled upon ice cream and thought, WHY NOT. This shop was small. You can also taste before buying. I tried almost all the flavors hehe. In...
Kayley C.
1/30/2025
The salted caramel brownie with marshmallow fluff was DELISH. I really like that they have rotating flavors. There was plenty of outdoor seating which is great after a long hike with dogs!
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.