Linda L.
8/23/2025
Love love love the Pizza. Some of the staff members aren't very pleasant but the pizza it makes up for it I guess. The godfather is one of my favs. Give it a try.
Paul's Live From New York Pizza
Permanently closed
(450)
Photos
604 F St
Eureka, CA 95501
Paul's Live From New York Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant located in Eureka, CA. Known for their authentic New York-style pizzas, this establishment offers a menu filled with delicious options for pizza lovers.
With two locations already established and a third one on the way, Paul's Live From New York Pizza is expanding its reach to cater to more customers. Whether you prefer to order online for delivery or place your order over the phone, they provide convenient options for a satisfying pizza experience.
Generated from the website content
Also at this address
Reviews
3.5450 reviews
D A.
8/4/2025
Cavernous, bare bones, crappy speakers, and only the ambiance you bring in, But you're not here for that. Seriously massive slices and lots of screens with sports. Choices of beer. Also the...
Amy S.
1/29/2025
I feel like this spot has a lot of potential here but just misses the mark. A local spot, very popular. Not so much for dine in as more for take out and third party. You can do a simple slice or...
Jimmie Ray A.
8/31/2025
Pizza is usually Great. Customer Service is on a whole different lowest of low level. I had a long day of work and went to pick up my pizza, that I requested to be ready for pick up at 3:40 PM on...
D. G.
8/10/2025
I've been coming here every time I'm in town for 20 years. Paul runs a well-oiled machine, and his thin crispy slices rival anything that comes from that other coast. Toppings are creative and...
See a problem?
