F S.
9/19/2025
Ermergerd!!!! Aka DELICIOUS!!! This pizza was so good. The atmosphere was perfect. Felt like we stepped into a time/space warp and landed in Chicago. If you know about Chicago deep dish. Then...
Old Chicago Pizza
Permanently closed
(50)
Photos
1390 N McDowell Blvd Ste H
Petaluma, CA 94954
Old Chicago Pizza, established in 1978, is a renowned restaurant located in the heart of historic downtown Petaluma, California. Known for serving traditional Chicago Style Deep Dish pizza, the establishment has been a staple in the community for over 40 years, inviting guests to enjoy their meals in a beautiful historic setting.
In addition to their signature deep dish offering, Old Chicago Pizza provides a variety of crust options including Double Crust, Thin Crust, Extra Thin Crust, and Gluten-Free Thin Crust pizzas. Whether dining in or opting for delivery, patrons can savor authentic Chicago pizza from the comfort of their own homes.
Generated from the website
Also at this address
Reviews
3.550 reviews
Austin W.
8/18/2025
I've been going to Old Chicago Pizza for years for their deep dish pizza and unfortunately, I've noticed quality has gone down consistently over the years. I can no longer justify paying $52 for a...
Bryan G.
11/17/2025
Wow, I just went to pick up a pizza and was literally almost accosted by Audrey the woman at the register. As the cook was wrapping up my food I hadn't even got a word out of my mouth as I just...
Kay O.
9/15/2024
That Chicago pizza had a little pop-up takeout shop over here and this is down the street from my house!! Lol I only knew about their location in downtown, which is maybe 2 miles away from my...
Leslie H.
9/24/2025
Hands down the best service and best Chicago deep dish style pizza! The service is always on point and the bakers make the pizzas consistent every single time we order!! I called in tonight to let...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Foursquare.