Renee F.
9/25/2025
The employees are always friendly. The restaurant is always clean. The food is fresh. Ordering online is a fail 100% of the time. I don't know why I continue to try. The sandwiches are NEVER...
Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop - Newark, CA
$
Closed
(166)
Photos
5849 Jarvis Ave
Newark, CA 94560
Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop is a premium sandwich shop. Our shops offer hand sliced proprietary proteins and cheeses topped with sauces that are made daily. All sandwiches are served on our fresh baked rolls, including our famous Dutch Crunch roll. Mr. Pickle's Sandwich Shop offers best in class sandwiches including the famous Big Jake, Reuben, and of course The Mr. Pickle. Our twenty- six plus years of success is rooted in the simple formula of "Making the Guest Happy" by providing craveable sandwiches, exceptional guest service, and local community involvement.
Reviews
3.5166 reviews
Shaun B.
11/23/2025
Went to Mr. Pickle this past weekend after running errands and wasn't sure what to expect since it's been a while. I ordered the Mr. Pickle with the Works and a Mrs. Pickle, both on Dutch crunch....
Jodelyn A.
10/28/2025
Came here to get a quick bite to eat while my daughter had a tutoring session in the area. This was my first time eating here and I definitely enjoyed the sandwich I got. I ordered the Baja...
Carol N.
10/4/2025
2nd chance for redemption thanks to colleagues and I will say this time around was a much better experience. Ordered with DoorDash during the Happy Hour period so 30% off which is what made me...
Shine S.
6/2/2025
A refund of the drink and chips would be nice. Sandwiches were not made with the extra items purchased. And the combo order was missing Cheeto chips and cookie. It seems like this Newark...
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.