Chad O.
6/8/2025
This is an amazing NY pizza place in a small strip mall. It's nit a huge place and has some limited seating. Pizza places in thus area that have traditional said they have NY pizza have never...
Colosseum New York Pizza
$
Closed
(1,405)
Photos
761 E Capitol Ave
Milpitas, CA 95035
Colosseum New York Pizza, located in Milpitas, CA, has established itself as a beloved pizzeria in the local community, offering a diverse selection of pizzas and Italian dishes. Renowned for its classic cheese pizza, garlic knots, and hearty calzones, the restaurant caters to a variety of tastes and preferences, making it a popular dining choice for residents.
Partnered with Slice since 2024, Colosseum New York Pizza emphasizes convenience with options for curbside pickup and a user-friendly ordering experience. With years of experience serving delicious meals, this pizzeria continues to be a staple for those looking to indulge in quality Italian cuisine.
Generated from the website
Find related places
Reviews
4.01,405 reviews
Cesar C.
11/5/2025
I've been coming here for a few years. Same order I always get, costs $10 more under the new ownership. After I let new owner that $46 was ridiculous for a large pizza, she gave me a $3 discount....
Brandom K.
9/29/2025
Sept 29, 2025. This place has apparently been sold several months back. I had bought the calzone, stromboli and cheese pizza several times. #1Cheese pizza seems the same. Which is good cause...
Jeff F.
9/15/2025
A bona fide spot for well-seasoned eats! Garlic knots ($11): chewy, slightly crispy with extra garlic and butter, 5/5 stars. Garlic fries ($9): simple but perfect. Crispy and garlic salted fries...
Briana V.
9/18/2025
I know that Colosseum pizza has been in Milpitas for quite some time, but I was finally able to try it as it really wasn't a go to pizza spot when I lived here. I ordered a pizza by the slice...
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.