Chapala Cafe

$$
Closed
yelp logo

(159)

Photos

201 2nd St
Eureka, CA 95501

History

Chapala Cafe was opened by Rita Pimentel (of Rita's fame) in the small trailer restaurant on Wabash and C in 1988. Our current space in Old Town Eureka was an Italian restaurant named Sergio's which closed in 1991. Chapala moved here in 1992 and I started working for Rita as a server. In 1996, Rita and Elias offered my wife Shelley and me the opportunity to purchase the restaurant. Rita agreed to stay on as mentor for all things kitchen related and the rest is history. Chapala has served over a million customers and was voted Humboldt County's best Mexican Restaurant in 2003, 2004, 2008 and 2009.

Specialties

Chile Rellenos - Fresh Anaheim Chiles stuffed with cheese then grilled with a light egg batter Tamales - Homemade chicken tamales Baja Tacos - Dollar-sized, soft, double corn tortilla tacos with your choice of grilled Fish, Carne Adobada, Carne Asada, Pollo Asado or Carnitas. Topped with chopped tomato, onion and cilantro. Carnitas - Tasty, lightly grilled shredded pork that has been marinated with lime juice and salt. Margaritas - The Best Margaritas on the corner of Second and C Street! The house margarita features Jose Cuervo Gold and comes with a choice of regular, strawberry, raspberry, mango or pineapple/orange flavors.

Reviews

yelp logo
3.5159 reviews
Photo of Joey H.
Joey H.
7/8/2025

The chilaquiles were some of the best in Humboldt. Waiter was on top of it and fast. Margaritas were nice and strong.

Photo of B B.
B B.
4/29/2025

The food is good. Very authentic. Service was good too, maybe because we were the only table there at the moment. Burritos are huge and can split between 2 people. They give you a basket of chips...

Photo of Cassey L.
Cassey L.
5/28/2025

Had a few really good meals here in the last few weeks. Service is always quick and the food always great! I'm a fan of the enchiladas and quesadillas, my lil nephew is a big fan of the rice and...

Alisa E.
8/14/2025

Best Mexican food in Humboldt. Our waiter Cesar was very knowledgeable and did an excellent job! The food was great!

Photo of Kathy T.
Kathy T.
12/13/2024

Our favorite Mexican food locally. The friendliest staff, beautifully decorated for the holidays, tastiest margaritas , excellent service for a party of over 30 people . They did an amazing job!...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesCaliforniaEurekaChapala Cafe

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.

Partial Data by Foursquare.