Al's New York Cafe

$
Closed
yelp logo

(794)

Photos

1673 Irvine Ave Ste B
Costa Mesa, CA 92627
Authentic New York style pizza right here in Costa Mesa, CA! Folks don't always know what makes New York Style pizza so special, but it has a long and proud history. These hand-tossed, thinner-crust pies are sold in wider slices that are crisp along the edge, and still soft in the middle so you can fold your slice for easier eating. They actually are much closer to original Italian pies than most pizza! And at Al's, the Italian heritage of our dishes is of the utmost importance to us. Our top quality, fresh ingredients make our calzones, salads, specialty entrees, pasta, deli sandwiches, and hot sandwiches and subs a real stand-out from the rest. However, it's our service that keeps our customers coming back again and again. At Al's, everyone is family. We know your name, your kid's names, and where they go to school. We want to make you comfortable, and stuff you full of delicious Italian food! But don't take our word for it, come see for yourself!

Reviews

yelp logo
4.0794 reviews
Photo of Sonia Alisa J.
Sonia Alisa J.
8/12/2025

Al's New York Café - A True New York Pizza Gem in Costa Mesa My husband has been telling me about Al's New York Café forever. We finally had an appointment in Newport Beach, and he asked the...

Photo of Gavin N.
Gavin N.
9/11/2025

Went to Al's New York Cafe to get a couple of slices of Pepperoni Pizza, and they did not disappoint. The thin crust New York style pizza is my favorite slice of pizza when ordering and this here...

Photo of Pedro F.
Pedro F.
5/19/2025

So nice I ate there twice. My daughter had an event just down the street so saw New York cafe and had to try. Absolutely loved the hot sandwiches, the portions are generous you can share. The...

Photo of Kathryn M.
Kathryn M.
8/28/2025

Long time customer- LOVE the Greek salad and pizza- the best! Just had the lasagna- only available Weds/Friday. It tastes like someone's mom/nonna made it with love!

Photo of Jack H.
Jack H.
8/24/2025

Really guys? Third time here and it was burnt. 4 pm on a Sunday. Not busy. Last time I did delivery and ranch never made it. I guess when I order pick up I need to not only check the toppings,...

Own this business?
See a problem?

You might also like

United StatesCaliforniaCosta MesaAl's New York Cafe

Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.