Paige C.
5/12/2024
I called this place up to see if they would make up a cookie for my girlfriend on Mother's Day. The lady I spoke with was so nice and very helpful. It took about 10 mins to tell her about what I...
Great American Cookies
$
Closed
(5)
Photos
4201 N Shiloh Dr
Fayetteville, AR 72703
What started with a generations-old family Cookie Cake recipe in 1977 with only the best premium ingredients, Great American Cookies is the sweet spot for happiness and joy. We are still the home of the original Cookie Cake, just re-imagined with life's sweet moments as our inspiration. Passionate bakers are devoted to hand-crafting fresh-baked Cookies, Double Doozies, and of course our custom-designed original Cookie Cakes. With bakeries across the country, in your neighborhood, and treats available for delivery right to your door, the sweet spot is always close to home.
Also at this address
Reviews
3.05 reviewsGeorgina A.
7/24/2025
We have done business with Great American Cookie in both locations, and this has to be the worst experience let alone the worst Customer Service. I asked to speak to the Store Manager and...
Linda B.
10/19/2023
went to pick up a cookie that I ordered and it wasn't ready. still needed the wording on it and the girl told me that it was a lot of words and and that the balloons wouldn't fit with the words. i...
Siena H.
9/13/2016
This place has my favorite cookies and my roommates love them too!! Every time I say I'm going to the mall they always want me to bring some back and they have great deals every time I'm there....
Aric D.
8/25/2015
Great American Cookies does not sell milk. There is nothing great or American about having to eat my chocolate chip cookie without milk to wash it down.
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.