Larry M.
5/17/2025
Conestoga Steak is THE place to get a steak. Properly prepared and served just the way it should be. Service is smooth and attentive. Sides are adequate and nice. Ambiance is 'old Alabama...
Conestoga Steak House
$$
Closed
(123)
Photos
3549 Montgomery Hwy
Dothan, AL 36303
Conestoga Steak House is a Dothan staple that has been around for over 43 years. We are a family owned business that strives to offer you and your family the best steak in town. We are famous for our variety of steaks with a side of a good ole’ baked potato. At Conestoga Steak House, we always use fresh, never frozen, USDA Choice Midwestern Beef. We also take special care to cut and trim steaks for quality and weight each to ensure proper portions. All steaks are char-grilled with our special steak sauce. Come on in and enjoy the wonderful food yourself!
Also at this address
Reviews
4.0123 reviews
Andrew P.
4/22/2025
Went there with my wife. We both got different cuts of beef. Both were absolutely fork tender. Steak topping was nice as well as the sides. Service was top nitch.
Adam M.
1/22/2025
Large ribeye medium rare, fries, ranch for the salad. Ask for extra sauce and real butter for the rolls. Conestoga is undefeated.
Johnny C.
2/8/2025
The service was great but I'm sure my steak was not fresh. It had a slightly rancid taste and was undercooked. A steak house should know how to prepare a steak properly especially if they describe...
Shane T.
8/21/2024
It's a very good restaurant and they know steak !! Limited menu which makes what they have great!!
Owner verified
See a problem?
You might also like
Partial Data by Infogroup (c) 2025. All rights reserved.
Partial Data by Foursquare.